Dragon Ball Super Broly movie analysis has to start with an uncomfortable truth. The original Broly was terrible. He was a walking plot hole with muscles who hated Goku because he cried as a baby forty years ago. That was his entire motivation. The 2018 film didn't just bring this character back from the dead, it performed surgery on him. It cut out the cancerous backstory and replaced it with something that actually makes you care when he starts screaming and breaking planets. This is the Broly that should have existed from the start, and the movie around him is the best thing Dragon Ball has put on a screen in decades. The fixes everything wrong with the franchise formula while keeping the punches coming hard enough to rattle your teeth. It proves you can have real character writing and still end the movie with two gods trying to murder each other across an arctic wasteland. That's the balance this thing strikes, and it nails it. The film isn't perfect. The music gets too loud sometimes and the CGI looks like a PlayStation 2 cutscene in spots. But when it works, which is most of the time, it's unmatched. You get a tragic backstory that hits hard, a fight that lasts longer than most TV episodes, and animation that looks like the manga came to life and started moving. If you skipped this because you thought Broly was just a meme character, you need to fix that mistake. This is the real deal. It's the standard every anime movie should be trying to hit right now.
The opening act spends thirty minutes on Planet Vegeta and it doesn't feel like filler. We see King Vegeta being jealous of a baby. We see Paragus losing his mind when his son gets exiled. We see Bardock actually acting like a father who loves his wife Gine. This stuff matters because it gives weight to everything that comes later. When Broly finally shows up on Earth, you understand why he's angry. You understand why he's broken. The movie earns your investment before a single punch gets thrown. That's rare for Dragon Ball. Usually they just want to get to the explosions. This one takes its time and the story is better for it. Akira Toriyama wrote the script himself this time and it shows. He took a character he barely knew from old non-canon movies and gave him a soul. The old Broly was just Kakarot this and Kakarot that. This Broly is a kid who got stranded on a hostile planet with an abusive dad. Paragus put a shock collar on him. He treated him like a dog. He raised him to be a weapon for revenge against a dead king. That's heavy stuff for a series that usually resolves conflicts with who can punch harder. It makes Broly sympathetic even when he's trying to kill Vegeta. You don't want him to die at the end. You want him to get help. That emotional hook changes everything about how you watch the fight scenes. When he goes Full Power and loses his mind, it isn't cool. It's terrifying and sad. You see a kid having a breakdown because his dad pushed him too far. That's way more interesting than just watching another bad guy flex. The best film breakdown covers how this reimagining works on every level. The animation style deserves its own paragraph because it's completely different from the TV series. Naohiro Shintani directed this thing and he threw out the rigid Super style. The lines are loose and sketchy. The colors are softer but they pop more. The characters actually have facial expressions that change. Frieza looks condescending and cruel in ways he never did before. Broly looks genuinely sweet when he's talking to Cheelai, then he looks like a monster when the rage takes over. The transformation sequences aren't just golden hair and aura. They look painful. They look like the body is breaking and rebuilding itself. When Vegeta goes Super Saiyan God, the red glow looks like it's actually emitting light. It's not just a filter slapped over the cel. They put real money and time into making this look gorgeous. But then they had to go and use CGI for some shots and it sticks out like a sore thumb. When Broly is powering up and the camera spins around him in 3D, it looks like a video game asset rotating on screen. It breaks the immersion. The 2D animation is so good that the 3D moments feel like a betrayal. You go from watching beautiful hand-drawn combat to watching a cutscene from Dragon Ball Z Kakarot. It's jarring. They should have stuck with the 2D for the whole thing. The budget was clearly there. They just got lazy in spots or ran out of time.
The fight itself is the main attraction and it doesn't disappoint. It's forty minutes long. That's not an exaggeration. The fight starts and it doesn't stop for forty straight minutes of screen time. Vegeta fights Broly first and gets pushed to Blue. Then Goku steps in and gets pushed to Blue. Then Frieza kills Paragus to trigger the Super Saiyan transformation. Then Gogeta shows up and fights Legendary Super Saiyan Broly. It keeps escalating. The geography changes. They start in an icy wasteland and end up breaking through mountains and lava fields. Broly learns as he fights. He starts out raw and unskilled but he adapts to Vegeta's tactics. He copies movements. He gets stronger every time he gets hit. It's not just beam spamming. There's actual martial arts choreography. You can see the influences from classic kung fu films. The camera moves in ways that show off the speed without making it confusing. You feel every impact. When Broly punches Goku through a glacier, you feel the cold and the impact. The sound design helps. Every hit sounds like a cannon going off. The 40 minute fight details break down exactly how they structured this marathon. Gogeta finally being canon is huge for fans. We've seen him in Fusion Reborn but that wasn't canon. This is the real deal. The fusion dance scene is funny without killing the tension. Goku and Vegeta screw it up twice before getting it right. When Gogeta finally appears, he's perfect. He talks trash while beating Broly senseless. He uses the Soul Punisher and the Kamehameha. He's powerful but not cruel. He wants to stop Broly without killing him. That shows growth for both Goku and Vegeta. The fight choreography for Gogeta is even more fluid than the rest of the movie. He moves like he's dancing while he fights. It's beautiful to watch. The only downside is that the music during this part is mixed way too loud. You can barely hear the dialogue over the drums and guitars. It's a recurring problem in the film. Norihito Sumitomo's score is good but the audio mixing treats it like it's the only thing that matters. During quiet moments between Broly and Cheelai, the music swells and drowns out the voice acting. You have to turn the volume down during fights and up during talking scenes. It's annoying. The Broly vs Gogeta theme slaps though. It's just too loud. Cheelai and Lemo are the secret weapons of this movie. They aren't just exposition delivery systems. Cheelai is a thief with a conscience. Lemo is an old soldier who's tired of fighting. They treat Broly like a person, not a weapon. When Cheelai steals the Dragon Balls at the end to wish Broly back to his home planet, it's earned. She sees that he's innocent. She sees that Paragus broke him. That relationship gives the movie heart. Without them, Broly would just be a monster. With them, he's a victim. Frieza provides the comedy relief and he's never been funnier. He wants to use the Dragon Balls to get taller. That's his entire motivation. He's still evil. He still kills Paragus to trigger Broly's transformation. But he's also petty and insecure about his height. It makes him more interesting than just being the big bad. Beerus babysitting Bulla is another funny moment that breaks up the seriousness. It reminds you that this is still Dragon Ball. It's allowed to be silly even when it's being dramatic.
The Bardock stuff deserves special mention because they finally fixed him. The old TV special made him a ruthless killer who happened to have a vision. This version shows him as a dad who loves his wife. Gine is soft and kind. She worries about their baby. Bardock suspects Frieza is going to destroy the planet so he sends Goku away to save him. It's emotional. When he says they'll meet again someday, you know he dies minutes later. It makes Goku's entire origin story hit harder. We finally see him as a baby with his parents. We see why he became the kind person he is. It retcons the harsh Saiyan culture just enough to make it interesting again. The Planet Vegeta destruction scene is beautiful and horrifying. You see the fear in the Saiyans' eyes. You see Frieza's finger flick destroying everything. It sets the stage perfectly for Broly's resentment. He was exiled because King Vegeta was jealous. He survived because his dad followed him. Everyone else died. That trauma shapes him. The animation during this prologue is gorgeous. The colors are warm and golden for the Saiyan planet, then cold and sterile for Frieza's ship. It looks like a different era of anime. It looks expensive.
Compared to Battle of Gods and Resurrection F, this is on another level. Battle of Gods was good but it was mostly Beerus eating and Goku getting slapped around. Resurrection F was a mess with bad CGI and a rushed plot. Broly takes the time to set things up. It doesn't assume you know everything. It explains who the Saiyans were. It explains why Frieza is back. It gives Broly a complete arc from innocent child to raging monster to peaceful survivor. The pacing is slow for the first hour but it pays off. When the fight starts, you care about everyone involved. That's the difference. The other movies just wanted to get to the punching. This one wants you to understand why the punching matters. The Blu-ray release had issues with a green tint that made dark scenes look muddy. Some copies had compression artifacts that made it look like VHS quality. That's inexcusable for a movie that looks this good. The Japanese release didn't have these problems. If you're buying it, get the 4K version or the newer prints. The green tint ruins the beautiful color palette that Shintani worked so hard to create. It's a shame because the movie deserves better presentation. Vic Mignogna played Broly in the English dub and there's controversy around him now, but his performance was great. He captured Broly's gentleness and his rage perfectly. Sean Schemmel and Christopher Sabat are at the top of their game as Goku and Vegeta. The scream work in this movie must have destroyed their vocal cords. Everyone sounds invested. The Japanese cast is obviously great too, but the English dub holds up. Broly is currently living on Planet Vampa with Cheelai and Lemo, but he's training with Goku and Vegeta sometimes. That's the setup for the future. He's not a villain anymore. He's a rival. He's the third strongest being in the universe after the fusion and the angels. That's a huge shift for the franchise. They can tell new stories with him. They don't have to keep bringing back old villains. Broly is new canon that opens up possibilities. Dragon Ball Super Broly movie analysis isn't just about looking back at a good film. It's about recognizing that Dragon Ball can still evolve. It can still surprise you. It can take a broken character from the 90s and make him the best part of the modern era. The fights are too long for some people. The CGI is ugly in spots. The music is mixed poorly. But none of that ruins what works. What works is the heart. What works is the animation when it's firing on all cylinders. What works is Broly himself, finally being treated like a real character instead of a meme. If you haven't seen this yet, you're missing the best Dragon Ball movie ever made. It's better than the original Broly films. It's better than Battle of Gods. It's the new gold standard. Go watch it. Fix your setup so the green tint doesn't ruin it. Turn the volume down during the fight scenes so your speakers don't blow. But watch it. It's worth your time. 
Dragon Ball Super Broly Movie Analysis
Frequently Asked Questions
How is the new Broly different from the old Broly?
The 2018 version reimagines Broly as a tragic victim of parental abuse rather than a mindless monster. He hates fighting and only loses control due to his father's shock collar and trauma. The old Broly hated Goku because he cried as a baby, which was stupid. The new Broly has real emotions and relationships with Cheelai and Lemo that make him sympathetic.
How long is the final fight scene?
It's about forty minutes long without stopping. It starts with Vegeta fighting Broly, then Goku takes over, then Frieza kills Paragus to trigger Super Saiyan, and finally Gogeta shows up to finish it. The geography changes from ice to lava as they break the landscape apart.
Is Gogeta canon in this movie?
Yes, Gogeta is officially canon for the first time. Goku and Vegeta perform the fusion dance twice before getting it right, and Gogeta appears in his base form, Super Saiyan Blue, and uses the Soul Punisher attack.
Why does the animation look different from Dragon Ball Super?
Naohiro Shintani changed the art direction to use looser, sketchier line work and softer colors that look more like the original manga. However, some scenes use CGI that looks like a video game cutscene, which clashes with the beautiful 2D animation.
What's wrong with the Blu-ray release?
The first print Blu-rays had a green tint and compression artifacts that made dark scenes look muddy. The 4K release and later prints fixed this. If you're buying it, avoid the original Blu-ray release if possible.